Judge Not That Ye Be Not Judged – Session Overview Podcast Episode

We have heard the phrase, judge not that ye be not judged, countless times in our lifetimes. Often it is used by the judgee to tell the judger that they have no right to judge them. While that may or may not be true, depending on the circumstance, it is not what Jesus intended. When He used the word “judge” He was referring to a person who has the authority and obligation to judge. As a verb it carried the same foundational meaning. His point was that we are not to sit in judgment over other people and condemn them for their actions. We don’t have that right. As Jesus’ little brother James put it, “There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the One who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you who judge your neighbor?” (James 4:12 – LSB)

However, Jesus was not implying that we just look the other way when sin rears its ugly head. In fact, He tells us in this sermon and in other places that we are to examine the motives of other people, not to try, judge, and execute them, but to see them for what they are and respond appropriately. He uses terms like dogs, pigs, and wolves to describe them and, in each case, gives warnings about them. (Matthew 7:6 & 15; 10:16) He wants us to make judgment calls on people for our own protection and in order to help them get the speck (splinter) out their eye. (Matthew 7:5, Galatians 6:1) The goal is restoration – not condemnation.

In order to meet this goal we must first deal with our own issues and our own sin. (Matthew 7:5) We must get the 2X4 out of our own eye before we try to help someone else with a little sawdust in their eye. When we make that judgment call we should know we’re on solid ground spiritually (and not just about the matter at hand, but in every area of our lives) and then proceed with caution. We must be wise as snakes and innocent as doves when Jesus sends us out into the world to speak His truth in love.

Transcript:

Pip: Welcome to From The Back Porch — where the sermons are warm, the porch is figurative, and the theological questions are sharper than they look.

Mara: Bob’s been working through the Sermon on the Mount, and this episode we’re sitting with one of the most quoted and most misread lines in the New Testament — what Jesus actually meant when he said don’t judge.

Pip: Let’s get into it.

Judge Not — What Jesus Actually Meant

Mara: The question this post puts on the table is whether “judge not” means what most people think it means — because the popular reading and the biblical reading turn out to be very different things.

Pip: The post draws on James to sharpen the point, and the line lands hard: “There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the One who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you who judge your neighbor?”

Mara: So the upshot is that condemning another person — bringing the gavel down by your own standard — is a role that simply doesn’t belong to us. That’s not a judgment call; that’s a usurpation.

Pip: And yet the post is careful not to let that become a blanket excuse for looking the other way. Jesus uses the words dogs, pigs, and wolves — which are not exactly terms of endearment — and each one is a call to assess, to discern, to make a judgment call for your own protection and for theirs.

Mara: Right. The distinction the post draws is between condemnation and discernment. One is forbidden; the other is actually required.

Pip: There’s a whole section on the log-and-speck passage — the 2×4 in your own eye before you address the splinter in someone else’s. The sequence matters: self-examination first, then restoration.

Mara: Galatians 6:1 gets quoted in the class transcript to reinforce exactly that: “you who are spiritual, restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness, each of you looking to yourself so that you will not also be tempted.” Gentle, humble, and with the awareness that next time it could be you in the ditch.

Pip: So fruit inspection is allowed — encouraged, even — but only after you’ve checked your own orchard first.

Mara: The post closes by framing the whole thing as a posture: Christians are to be aware of the actions and motives of others not to condemn them, but to help them and pray for them. The goal, stated plainly, is restoration — not condemnation.

Mara: The Sermon on the Mount keeps turning out to be more demanding than it first appears — not softer, but more precise.

Pip: Next time, more from the porch. Bring your Bible — and maybe a log splitter.

Leave a Reply